COMMERCIAL BEER REVIEWS by Kendall Staggs
OKTOBERFESTS
Have you had any good beers lately? Here are some brief reviews of
brews that I have recently tasted. Oktoberfest season has actually come
and gone, but many of these beers are still available in our local
stores.
1 Hacker-Pschorr Oktoberfest: Here is one that I purchased in Oklahoma
(of all places). Currently it is not available in Oregon. It was the
best Oktoberfest that I tasted this year. It was deep copper in color,
and tasted caramelly and somewhat sweet, with lots of authentic German
malt character. The noble hops were just right for perfect balance.
Bring on the brats and kraut. (5.7 percent abv)
2 Ayinger Oktober Fest-Märzen: This was the second best Oktoberfest
that I tasted this year. It was bright amber in color, with a big lacy
head. It also featured plenty of Bavarian-accented malt flavors, plus a
taste of homemade bread. This beer finished with gentle, floral hop
notes and a spicy-dry aftertaste. Ayinger is one of my favorite German
breweries, and its Oktober Fest-Märzen is available all year. (5.8
percent abv)
3 Goose Island Oktoberfest: This was my favorite American Oktoberfest
this year (special thanks to Scott Caul for providing me with a
sample). It was deep copper in color, and had a sweet, somewhat fruity,
big malt character. The only "flaw" in this beer was rather generous
amount of bittering hops, but at least they were noble hops. All of
Goose Island's beers are exceptional. Look for them when you visit
Chicago. (5.5 percent abv)
4 Full Sail Oktoberfest: This was the best of the local Oktoberfests
this year. It was red-amber in color and moderately full-bodied. It
featured a rich, toasted malt aroma, lots of malt flavor, subtle hop
accents, and medium hop bitterness. This was a solid domestic
interpretation. (5.4 percent abv)
5 Mt. Angel Oktoberfest: This was another good one, from the now
defunct Nor'Wester / Saxer brewing organization of Lake Oswego. Did
Portland Brewing brew this year's batch, or was it already brewed before
Saxer closed? Inquiring minds want to know. Anyway, this was amber in
color and with a moderately sweet malt character and a good hop
balance. Very tasty. (5.5 percent abv)
6 Uncle Otto's Oktoberfest Märzenbeer: This is a respectable example of
the style from the Portland Brewing Company. It was red-amber in color
and medium-bodied, with mild hop bitterness and a subtle hop flavor.
This was definitely a toasty version, and it had a hint of grain
astringency. (5.7 percent abv)
7 Big Fat Tuba Oktoberfest: This is a mediocre effort from the Thomas
Kemper Brewing Company of Seattle. It had a decent malt flavor but was
not as lively as the better examples. (5.7 percent abv)
8 Widmer Oktoberfest: Widmer's Oktoberfest was only so-so. It was a
drinkable beer, but it lacked the rich, sweet malt character of the
tastier Oktoberfests. (5.5 percent abv)
MEMBER OF ROYAL FAMILY CRITICIZES OKTOBERFEST
A descendant of the German royal family that launched Munich's
Oktoberfest in 1810 criticized this year's organizers for turning the
event into what he claims is a moneymaking exercise devoid of its
Bavarian cultural heritage. Wittelsbach Prince Luitpold, a great
grandson of the last King of Bavaria, Ludwig III, said: "If you go to
the festival now there is little Bavarian music. In the beer tents you
hear things like 'New York, New York,' and there is barely a pair of
lederhosen to be seen. How can you get a taste of typical Bavarian
comfort if a table designed for eight is sold to 14?" Luitpold is also
unhappy that his brewery is not allowed to sell beer at the event.
In Munich Oktoberfest began September 16 and ended October 3. Astrid
Ganssen, an Oktoberfest spokesman, said: "We are on target to pass even
last year's record, where 6.5 million liters of beer and 400,000
sausages were consumed. This year we hope for more visitors than ever."
BEER HISTORY
"MÄRZEN" by Graham Lees
With the exception of the hybrid marketing concoctions of the late 20th
century, tracing the origins of our beer styles would surely be a
pleasant challenge for the great evolutionary sleuth Charles Darwin.
Most beer boasts an evolutionary history, often, but not always,
associated with the Industrial Revolution. Evidence suggests that the
copper-red Märzen style owes its existence to spying expeditions to
England by two young German-speaking pioneers of lager brewing.
Viennese Anton Dreher and his Munich contemporary Gabriel Sedlmayr
junior (pronounced Zay-dull-myer) visited England twice in the 1830s
during their Europe-wide quest for new brewing knowledge-armed with a
hollowed-out walking stick for secretly collecting samples.
At that time, brewing in England was more technically advanced than
elsewhere because England was the powerhouse of the Industrial
Revolution. In particular, methods of malting barley had already led to
the creation of paler colored beers. Bohemia's golden Pilsner was still
nine years away when Dreher, aged 23, and Sedlmayr first visited England
in 1833. Dreher was particularly attracted to the English pale ales.
Back home, Sedlmayr concentrated on developing scientific methods of
producing bottom-fermented beers, while Dreher at first tried brewing an
English ale.
But that was a dead-end in this evolutionary path. We don't know for
certain, but its seems that the Viennese palate was unimpressed with
Dreher's interpretations of English beer. His commercial rivals briefly
made capital by ridiculing him as Vienna's "English brewer." Undaunted,
Dreher reexamined his stock of knowledge and set about marrying the new
English malting techniques with bottom fermentation.
In the 1830s, the brewers of mainland Europe made only dark malts
because established kilning methods, often using wood fires, meant less
temperature con-trol. In England, brewers had access to coal and better
machinery, which gave them more control and enabled them to make paler
malts.
What Dreher achieved by the end of the 1830s was a beer that combined
the clean palate and crispness of a lager with the paler hues he had
admired in English ales. His marriage and adaptation of techniques
produced a new style of beer-methodically bottom-fermented and
copper-reddish-brown in color. The precise recipe and flavor is not
recorded and, in any case, he may have refined his new beer over several
years. For instance, it is unclear whether he isolated a particular
yeast at the beginning.
Dreher called his new beer "Schwechater Lagerbier," after the Vienna
suburb home of his brewery, and its popularity grew rapidly-giving him
the last laugh over those ridiculing rivals. Generically, Dreher's beer
may for a time have been dubbed "Wiener Typ"(Vienna style) after his
malting process, which produced a reddish caramelized crystal malt, but
the enduring name for his style is Märzen.
Ironically, the name was coined 30 years later by Josef Sedlmayr,
younger brother of Gabriel. Although bottom-fermenting techniques had
swept across Europe by 1870, beer color in Bavaria had remained dark
(Dunkel). But in 1871 Josef Sedlmayr, who had separated his brewing
activities from Gabriel years earlier, decided to produce a slightly
paler beer. Perhaps because of the old Sedlmayr-Dreher link, he chose
to brew a reddish "Vienna style" beer.
He called it "Märzenbier" because he had brewed it in March, although it
was September before he broached the first barrels for public judgment.
Traditionally, Bavarian brewers had produced large batches of beer in
March and April before the weather got too warm for brewing and then
stored it in cool places to use during summer. But by the 1870s this
practice was becoming obsolete with the development of mechanized
refrigeration.
This was also a time of railroad development, which enabled tens of
thou-sands of Bavarians to travel to the Munich Oktoberfest. Whether
Josef intended his new Märzenbier for the festival is unclear, but it
became the Oktoberfest beer style for the next 100 years and its
popularity spread. The style faded in Vienna after World War I. Sadly,
Märzen has in recent years been supplanted at the Oktoberfest by a
paler, less robust "Oktoberfestbier" to suit broader international
tastes. But even this beer still retains a deeper amber color than the
average lager beer.
Many south Bavarian breweries still faithfully reproduce Märzen, if only
in small quantities. Most of Munich's big brewers still brew a draft
Märzen at Oktoberfest time (September-October) for sale in their beer
halls, notably Hofbräu and Spaten (which incorporates Josef Sedlmayr's
Franziskaner brewery). Typically, a Bavarian Märzen will be copper-red,
with a full-bodied maltiness, a little spicy and dryish with an alcohol
by volume of around 5.5 percent.
In Austria, the term Märzen is applied loosely to any golden lager of
around 5 percent alcohol by volume, but a new wave of brewpubs in Vienna
has begun brewing red-brown beers that they call Märzen. These new
Vienna reds are malty, full bodied, fruity-dry and unfiltered, which may
have been the condition of Dreher's early brews. Two of the most
noteworthy are Salm (at Rennweg 8, near Schwarzenbergplatz), which has
an initial malt sweetness, a fruity dry finish and long aftertaste; and
Siebernstern (at Siebernstern Gasse 19), with a rich malt-fruitiness,
hints of spiciness and a dryish finish.
Siebernstern calls its interpretation a "Wiener Märzen," but of Dreher's
name there is no mention or commemoration in today's Austria, although
his Schwechat brewery still functions as part of the giant Bräu AG
group.
Dreher died prematurely in 1863-possibly from overwork-at the age of
only 53. He did live to see his Vienna style become one of the biggest
selling beers in mid-19th-century central Europe. He acquired a chain
of breweries across the Austro-Hungarian empire. One of them was in
Michelob, yet another German-Bohemian name borrowed by Adolphus Busch,
co-founder of the Anheuser-Bush giant.
It is left to Dreher's former Kobanya brewery in Budapest, now owned by
South African Breweries, to honor Dreher by recently naming several
brews after him. The beers are being made to rediscovered 19th-century
recipes and, of these, Dreher Export is thought to come closest to
Dreher's Vienna style, with an amber color, full-bodied malt flavor and
clean, dry finish.
This article originally appeared in "All About Beer" magazine, November
1996.

© 1995-2009 HOTV